HP’s Instant Ink subscription service is marketed as a convenient way to save on printer ink, but in reality, it’s a frustrating and overpriced scam that leaves users trapped in a cycle of escalating costs and restrictive terms. The premise sounds appealing—pay a monthly fee for a set number of printed pages, and HP ships you ink cartridges as needed. However, the execution is a masterclass in fleecing customers.

First, the pricing is absurd and keeps climbing. HP lures you in with seemingly reasonable plans, but they frequently jack up the rates, leaving subscribers paying far more than anticipated. Our experience was a nightmare: one month, we slightly exceeded our page allotment, and the bill skyrocketed to a jaw-dropping $60 (as much as a 4-pack of cartridges from the store). That’s highway robbery for a handful of extra pages! When you break it down, the cost per sheet is outrageously high—often more expensive than just buying ink outright. Generic cartridges from third-party brands are a fraction of the cost and deliver comparable quality without the subscription headache.

The real kicker comes when you try to escape. Cancel your Instant Ink subscription, and the cartridges HP sent you become useless. That’s right—HP remotely disables them, rendering perfectly good ink cartridges nothing more than expensive paperweights. This predatory tactic ensures you’re locked into their ecosystem or left high and dry.

In short, HP Instant Ink is a deceptive money pit. You’re far better off skipping this scam and buying generic cartridges from reputable third-party sellers. Save your money and your sanity—steer clear of Instant Ink.

compare printer brands